- 15 Samoa Joe:Impact Wrestling
- 14 Devon:Victory Road '12
- 13 Robbie E:Turning Point '11
- 12 Eric Young:Impact Wrestling
- 11 Gunner:TNA iMPACT!
- 10 Abyss:Genesis '11
- 9 Douglas Williams:Final Resolution '10
- 8 AJ Styles:TNA IMPACT!
- 7 Rob Terry:Live Event
- 6 Eric Young:Bound For Glory '09
- 5 Kevin Nash:Hard Justice '09
- 4 Mick Foley:TNA IMPACT!
- 3 Kevin Nash:Victory Road '09
- 2 AJ Styles:Destination X '09
- 1 Booker T:TNA IMPACT!